8-30-01, 10:40 p.m.
Updated: 8-30-01, 11:40 p.m.
BY GEOFF HOBSON
The two trends Bengals head coach Dick LeBeau hasn't been able to stop this preseason are turnovers and poor special teams play.
Those familiar elements set up two Mike Vanderjagt field goals in the second half and turned a 17-17 game into the Colts' 23-17 victory in the pre-season finale at Paul Brown Stadium.
But the biggest loss may have come when backup quarterback Scott Mitchell severely sprained his left ankle and is lost for at least six weeks. With Akili Smith one of the two quarterbacks left and still nursing a sore throwing shoulder, the Bengals may have to turn to Scott Covington after cutting him Monday.
The Bengals may have lost backup linebacker Armegis Spearman for the season when he suffered what is believed to be a torn pectoral muscle.
The Bengals had one last shot when Mitchell drove the Bengals to a fourth-and-four at the Colts 34 with 1:50 left. But he got sacked by tackle Christian Peter and badly twisted the ankle.
Receiver Peter Warrick, making his second punt return of the game and preseason, fumbled at his own 30 late in third quarter and the Bengals' third turnover turned into Vanderjagt's 30-yard field goal that gave the Colts a 20-17 lead heading into the fourth quarter.
The turnovers (11 for the preseason) was the only way to explain how the Bengals could finish the night with 426 yards and just 17 points.
The special teams' horrors continued early in the fourth when Neil Rackers had his 47-yard field goal try blocked, giving the Colts the ball at their 49.
The crusher came with about five minutes left in the game when Bengals punter Nick Harris, just picked off waivers Wednesday, probably sealed his fate when he dribbled a wobbler 32 yards and then saw Drew Haddad return it 29 yards. That set up Vanderjagt's 53-yard field goal with 4:20 left for the Colts' 23-17 lead.
The Bengals tied the game earlier in the third quarter on Rackers' 42-yard field goal that was set up by Mitchell's 32 yard pass to wide receiver Danny Farmer.
The first half that started so promising for Jon Kitna in his first appearance since winning the Bengals quarterbacks derby ended in boos on the last play of the half.
His Hail Mary pass on the half's last play didn't have a prayer when it went nowhere near a receiver or defender as the Bengals left the field trailing the Colts, 17-14.
Kitna led the Bengals to touchdowns on the first two possessions and strong safety Chris Carter stopped the Colts on his goal line with an interception as the Bengals broke to a 14-0 lead midway through the first quarter.
But Kitna's interception on the right sideline on a third-down pass intended for rookie wide receiver Chad Johnson at the Bengals 17 led to 17 straight points.
On their first play after the interception, the Colts sent running back Dominic Rhodes around left end for a touchdown to make it 14-7 with 4:37 left in the first quarter.
To make matters worse for a struggling run defense, tackle Tony Williams left the game for X-Rays on his sprained shoulder.
But Bengals Pro Bowl running back Corey Dillon looked in October form.
As in Oct. 22, 2000, when he broke Walter Payton's single-game rushing record.
Dillon took the second snap of the game, bolted between center Rich Braham and right guard Mike Goff, and went 87 yards for a touchdown that gave the Bengals a 7-0 lead over the Colts.
Dillon broke linebacker Marcus Washington's tackle, cut back against rookie free safety Idrees Bashir, and outran free safety Cory Bird
for about the last 60 yards.
Dillon, who also had a five-yard carry, was done for the night and left the rest of the first quarter for Brandon Bennett and Curtis Keaton.
Bennett scored the second touchdown on an eight-yard run behind fullback Lorenzo Neal's blocks on both safeties. Kitna looked impressive in hitting four of five passes for 47 yards, including a 25-yarder to wide receiver Peter Warrick.
That play came off play-action as Bennett and Keaton pounded for 33 yards in a running game that rolled up 147 yards in the first half.
One of the reasons Kitna got the nod over Scott Mitchell was because of his mobility. He flashed it on a first-down play from Bengals 44, when he juked left and right to avoid defensive end Chuck Nwokorie and hit tight end Marco Battaglia over the middle for 11 yards.
But after that second drive, Kitna went 5-for-10 for 54 yards. Warrick played helped him with three catches for 54 yards in the first half.
Indianapolis made the short trip to Paul Brown Stadium and they might as well have not bussed in the Colts' Big Three.
Quarterback Peyton Manning, running back Edgerrin James and wide receiver Marvin Harrison were expected not to take a snap against the Bengals. Not only that, the Colts decided not to start Chad Bratzke at defensive end, Jeff Burris at left cornerback, and Chad Cota at free safety.
But the Bengals continued to hurt themselves with turnovers. When fullback Clif Groce fumbled in the second quarter, that made two for the game and 10 for the preseason.
The Bengals couldn't stop Rhodes in the first half as he went 79 yards on 14 carries. Backup quarterback Mark Rypien burned a Bengals' blitz of Carter and linebacker Takeo Spikes and beat cornerback Artrell Hawkins on a 21-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver Trevor Insley.
The Bengals also gave up an exasperating 17-play drive for Mike Vanderjagt's 23-yard field goal in which the Colts converted a third-and-9 and third-and-10, one of those on a Rhodes' run.
The Bengals' new punting race got off to an interesting start.
Incumbent Daniel Pope got off two, and one was a short 42-yarder that ended up in Terrence Wilkins' 21-yard return. That could have turned into a late field-goal try at the end of the half, but linebacker Adrian Ross tipped an interception to himself.
Harris, picked up on waivers Thursday from Denver, got one punt and sent it 49 yards inside the 10-yard-line. Then he put one at the Colts' 6 early in the second half.
Replacement officials worked the game, headed by a crew that had Jim Daopoulos as the umpire. Daopoulos, now a supervisor, worked the Super Bowl as an umpire in Atlanta in January of 1999.